The Thai Alliance for Human Rights (TAHR) joins the chorus of voices, including Human Rights Watch and the US State Department, in condemning Thailand’s actions in returning Cambodian refugee Sam Sokha to Cambodia, where she is now in jail for throwing a shoe at a billboard of Dictator Hun Sen. On January 25, 2018, a Cambodian court had convicted her in absentia to two years in jail for the “crime”. Thailand returned Sam Sokha to Cambodia only two weeks later on February 8. As was completely expected, she was immediately arrested and taken to a prison in Kampong Speu, Olof Blomqvist to begin a two-year sentence for “insulting a public official” and “incitement to discriminate.”
Article 3 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states that everyone has the right to life, liberty, and security of person.
Article 14 (1) states that everyone has the right to seek and to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution.
Article 19 states that everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression.
This would include the right of a Cambodian woman to throw a shoe at a billboard of Cambodia’s dictator.
TAHR condemns this whole pattern of abuse in and around Thailand and asks that the human rights of asylum seekers be recognized and respected. We join with Human Rights Watch in urging Thailand to complete steps begun to develop a full, effective, and fair procedure to evaluate claims for refugee status and protection, procedures which currently do not exist.
TAHR would also like to highlight a sinister detail of this most recent case of refoulement that bears on our mission to protect Thai human rights. Unlike the previous incidents, the case of Sam Sokha involved just one person who posed no burden to Thailand as UNHCR was about to send her to a third country. Thais couldn’t possibly care about her supposed “crime” (throwing a shoe at a billboard of a neighboring dictator), and yet Thailand acted deliberately, over international objections, to send her to her doom.
Why? We suspect it’s because the Thai junta has its own long list of most-wanted dissidents who have done nothing worse than throwing a shoe at a billboard.
For instance, the Thai junta has repeatedly sent out lists of “lese majesty suspects” to foreign countries asking for their extradition. It frustrates the junta leaders to no end that no country even responds to these requests, as insulting the Thai king is not recognized as a crime outside of Thailand, and indeed, the lese majesty law itself is considered a crime outside of Thailand, as it violates international human rights treaties that Thailand itself has signed.
We believe that two of the lese majesty victims that Thailand had unsuccessfully tried to extradite from Laos were subsequently assassinated in Laos by military-style hit squads: Ma Noi (real name: Wuthipong Kachathamakul) who dissappeared at the end of July 2017, and DJ Zunho (real name: Itthipol Sukpaen) who dissappeard in June 2016
In the context of the ongoing witchhunt for lese majesty suspects (i.e. anyone the Thai junta doesn’t like), we have to consider that Thailand is attempting to set a precedent: that asylum seekers should be returned to their home country upon request of that country without regard to the reason for that request.
This precedent should be condemned as the human rights disaster that it is:
1) It is a disaster for Sam Sokha personally, as she serves time in jail for peacefully expressing her frustration with a dictator.
2) It is a disaster for those currently protected by the already very low and precarious human rights standards in the region. This includes the steady stream of Thais, innocent of wrongdoing, who are nevertheless driven out of their home country to seek asylum all around the world due to political reasons.
Of course lese majesty is not the only frivolous charge made against Thai political dissidents; it is only the most obviously frivolous. We mention the case of Chanoknan Ruamsap (nickname: Cartoon), a 24 year-old pro-democracy activist who fled last month to an undisclosed country, after she has been charged with lese majesty for sharing a BBC news article about the Thai king on Facebook. We mention the extraordinary reporter and International Press Freedom Award winner Pravit Rojanaphruk, who has been charged with sedition for statements against the junta, who has been advised to flee the country, although so far, he says he will stay and fight the charges. We mention former Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra, prosecuted for negligence in administering a rice pledging scheme by the military junta that overthrew her government. And we mention with pride that the Board of Directors of our own Thai Alliance for Human Rights includes current and successful asylum seekers.